Which app is better for your needs?

Here's a comparison of capabilities, to help you decide

Multiple customer types
Get a percentage discount for all orders
Tag customers automatically
Send email notifications on membership upgrade
Show discounted prices across all store,
not just in cart subtotal
Different discounts for different collections
Custom prices per product for each customer type
Discounts are based on "Price" field (current sale price) "Compare at price" field (MSRP)
or choose "Price" in Settings
or import CSV with prices
Get discounts only for orders above a minimum value or quantity
Volume discounts (buy more to get larger discount)
Tax exemption
Member benefits, such as Points or Credits,
used to purchase products
Membership subscriptions
  Get app Get app

Both apps can also work together.